Overall Conclusion

Overall Conclusion of five category among five brands.

• Normal Lipstick

The top of normal lipstick among five brands is L'Oreal Color Riche Moist Matte. 

• Matte Lipstick

The top of matte lipstick among five brands is L'Oreal Balmain Matte Lipstick.

• Liquid Lipstick

The top of matte lipstick among five brands is Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink.

• Pencil Eyeliner

The top of pencil eyeliner among five brands is Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil.

• Liquid Eyeliner

The top of liquid eyeliner among five brands is Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP.

Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil

Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil

Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil is a gel pencil eyeliner.
This is new pencil eyeliner from Kate.
It comes with 1.5 mm super fine tip which suitable for makeup beginners to use.
We had tried two colors which are BK-1,BR-1
As can be seen in the picture, the colour is high coloration which is pigmented.

Apart from the superfine tip, the melting-texture also enable to draw a smooth line which easier to draw inner eyeliner and also perfect sharp eye tail.Other than that, the texture also able to draw a eyeliner with small effort used. However, this eyeliner is quite few in amount which may be use up easily. 

After applied, we have test the waterproof, smudge and etc as we do in common. 

We found out that this pen eyeliner is consider the best in waterproof, smudge-proof and long lasting.

After 6 hours applied, the result show good as the liner almost still there and the colour is same as shown in picture. Besides, it is suitable to use in hot weather thanks to the high waterproof and smudge proof as it can keep a nice look of the eye along the day.

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁

Waterproof:😁😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof：😁😁😀😁😁
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://www.shinilola.com/2018/08/no-makeup-makeup-challenge-with-kate.html

Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP

Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP

This is another type of liquid eyeliner that launched by Kate

This type of eyeliner is aim to draw a super-fine eyeliner which produce a sharp liner.

It is the eyeliner that specially developed for Malaysia's customers.

There are only two black colour which are matte black (BK-2), and Glow black (BK-1) as shown in the picture.

This eyeliner have very high color pigmentation which look very deep in colour. 
Besides, as you will worry about the liquid liner will dry slowly but this exactly will dry faster than your expectation. Thus, it is easier to use as it dry fast which will not mess up your eye makeup. 
Moreover, thanks to superfine liner, it enable to draw eye tail perfect. 
However, it is not so suit to draw inner eyeliner as it hard due to liquid based. 
Apart from that, the best parts are there are also have strong waterproof and no smudging.


After 6 hours we use, we found out that this eyeliner can maintain the eyetail with perfect angle and will not smudge at all. 

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof：😁😁😁😁😁
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://www.kate-global.net/sg/sp/all_products/eye_liner.html

Silky Girl Perfect Matte Liquid Eyeliner Waterproof

Silky Girl Perfect Matte Liquid Eyeliner Waterproof 



This new liquid eyeliner has a flexible applicator brush that comes with a 0.3mm smart tip to create precise thin lines and bold thick lines; glides on smoothly onto eyelids making it perfect for beginners. 

With its excellent color pay-off and high coverage, this liner applies like a dream onto lash lines, drying to an intense matte black finish.

Silky Girl Perfect Matte Liquid Eyeliner Waterproof is 
the one of valuable liquid eyeliner that most of the people prefer it.


It provide two colour for the buyer to choose their favour which are 01 Black Colour and 02 Black Brown Colour

We evaluate the result as mention in the brand name this product does not come of by using water.

We also did some long-lasting test to test the product. 

The product is long-lasting as it mentioned in product name it, it can last 24 hours until does not touch our eyes or scrub our eyes. 

If we scrub our eyes hard, the product tend smear little amount in our face.







As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)
Color pigmentation:😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof：😁😁😁😁
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://journal.sociolla.com/beauty/review-silky-girl-perfect-matte-liquid-eyeliner-waterproof/

L'Oreal Infallible Gel Crayon 24h Waterproof

Gel Crayon Eyeliner is one of the most popular used eyeliner among females. This type of eyeliners is normally used by beginners since it is a easier to use. However, we put the L'Oreal Infallible Gel Crayon 24h Waterproof to the test.



Firstly, we test the product by doing the waterproof test.
Step 1: Swatch the eyeliner in our arms.

L'Oreal Infallible Gel Crayon 24h Waterproof

Step 2: Wait for 3 minutes to dry. 

Step 3: Flow the tap water on the arm for 5-6 minutes.

Step 4: Evaluate the outcome.

We evaluate the result as mention in the brand name this product does not come of by using water.

We also did some long-lasting test to test the product. The product is long-lasting as it mentioned in product name it, it can last 24 hours until does not touch our eyes or scrub our eyes. If we scrub our eyes hard, the product tend smear little amount in our face.

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.

(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁

Easy to use:😁😁😁😁😁

Waterproof:😁😁😁😁

Smudge proof:😁😁😁😁

Long-lasting:😁😁😁😁

Overall result:😁😁😁😁
More related review: https://makeupandbeauty.com/loreal-paris-24h-infallible-gel-crayon-eyeliner-106-rest-in-khaki-review/