Hello everyone!! 

We are the student of Sunway College Johor Bahru.
This blog created by Kirrthana, Quah Hui Qun, and Teo Ke Wen.
Our objective to create the blog to provide the differences among different. We are choosing the drugstore cosmetic brand with good quality in Malaysia. There are the brand of Kate, Maybelline, Revlon, SilkyGirl and Loreal Paris. Make up is the lesson that most of the girl want to study and select the good quality product is the one more important part that is the reason why we are doing this blog.πŸ‘©πŸ‘§πŸ‘ΈπŸ’‹

Overall Conclusion


Overall Conclusion of five category among five brands.


  • Normal Lipstick
The top of normal lipstick among five brands is L'Oreal Color Riche Moist Matte. 



  • Matte Lipstick
The top of matte lipstick among five brands is L'Oreal Balmain Matte Lipstick.



  • Liquid Lipstick
The top of matte lipstick among five brands is Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink.


  • Pencil Eyeliner
The top of pencil eyeliner among five brands is Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil.


  • Liquid Eyeliner
The top of liquid eyeliner among five brands is Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP.



Maybelline The Colossal Kajal

Maybelline The Colossal Kajal



Maybelline Colossal kajal is a pen eyeliner. It has a deep black pigment which enable to draw a deep black liner.
It is amazing as it enriched with nourishing ingredient which will soothe out eyes.
This type of eyeliner is well suited to draw inner liner as it is creamy based. 
The tip enable to glides on eyeliner with small effort used. 
However, as the creamy based, it tend to break easily if too much pressure applied. Thus, it must used with light hand. 

After applied, it shown a matte finish. It is long lasting as it will not smudge unless you smudge it with great effort. But it is waterproof enough as will not be gone easily caused by sweat. 


After 6 hours applied, the result show quite good as the liner almost still there but for the inner corner of eyes gone. Although is lasting but doesn't live up the product's claim of 12 hours staying power. We also found out that it is not suit for oily eyelid so it is advisable to use with setting spray or powder.
As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁
Smudge proof:😁😁

Long-lasting: 😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁


more related review:
https://www.stylecraze.com/articles/maybelline-colossal-kajal-review/

Maybelline Hyper ink liquid liner

Maybelline Hyper ink liquid liner 

When it comes to cosmetics market, there are few brands comes to our mind. These brands plays an vital role in the cosmetic industry. Among one of the brands is Maybelline. Maybelline is one of the popular brand in the cosmetics industrty. One of the popular product Maybelline is the Hyper ink liquid liner. 




Firstly, we test the product by doing the waterproof test.
Step 1: Swatch the eyeliner in our arms.


Step 2: Wait for 3 minutes to dry. 

Step 3: Flow the tap water on the arm for 5-6 minutes.

Step 4: Evaluate the outcome.

We evaluate that the product does not come off when we placed our hand under the water. After the five minutes are over, none of the product came off. This proves that the product is waterproof.





Other than that, we also did the long-lasting test to the product by wearing it until it start to melt and messy. As for the results it last long enough as an eyeliner until we does not touch or scrub our eyes. We think is a long-lasting product.


As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.

(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof:😁😁😁😁
Long-lasting:😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://makeupandbeauty.com/maybelline-hyperink-liquid-liner-black-review/

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink

Maybelline have launched several numbers of numbers of products in the past few years. Most of the products released by Maybelline is highly known among customers. One of the popular product of Maybelline is Super Stay Matte Ink. We want to put the product for the test.

Firstly, we test the product by doing the smear test.


Step 1: Swatch the Matte Gloss in our arms.

Step 2: Wait for 3 minutes to dry.

Step 3: Compress the tissue in our arms.

Step 4: Evaluate the outcome.

We swatch three different colours from the same brand which have the colour code of 30,40 and 60. We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue.


This product seem to smear quite a lot. Most of the products are in the tissue.


Last but not least, we also did some long- lasting test on the product. By using applying it to our lips and test how long it is going to stay on our lips. All the colour reach the same period of time which is about two hours to lose big portion of our product from our lips. However, the shade of the colour stayed in our lips almost 3.5 hours until it completely gone from the lips.

Smear Test: 😁😁😁
Long lasting:😁😁😁
Color Pigmentation:😁😁😁😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁


More related review:
https://beautymnl.com/products/22750-superstay-matte-ink-liquid-lipstick

Maybelline Color Sensational Creamy Matte Lipstick

Maybelline Color Sensational Creamy Matte Lipstick

As everybody knew that Matte Lipstick is one of the widely used lipsticks among women. The matte lipstick is also plays a role of a basic cosmetic product which are with almost every female who wears make-up. Now, we put the Maybelline Color Sensational Creamy Matte Lipstick to the test.





One of the test that we did is smear test.
Step 1: Swatch the Matte Lipstick in our arms.

Step 2: Wait for 3 minutes to dry.

Step 3: Compress the tissue in our arms.

Step 4: Evaluate the outcome.



We swatch two different colours from the same brand which are Craving Coral(685) and Siren in Scarlet(690). We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue. This product seem to smear quite a little. The Siren in Scarlet (690) seem to quite more because it have some bright colour which makes it more visible.

Last but not least, we also did some long- lasting test on the product. By using applying it to our lips and test how long it is going to stay on our lips. All the colour reach the same period of time which is about two hours to lose big portion of our product from our lips. However, the shade of the colour stayed in our lips almost 6 hours until it completely gone from the lips.

Smear Test: 😁😁😁
Long lasting:😁😁😁😁
Color Pigmentation:😁😁😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁


More related review:
https://www.makeupalley.com/product/showreview.asp/ItemId=174137/Color-Sensational-Creamy-Matte-Lip-Color/Maybelline-New-York/Lipstick

Maybelline The Loaded Bolds by Color Sensational

Maybelline The Loaded Bolds by Color Sensational

Maybelline have launched a number of products in the cosmetic industry. They also released some products which have some bold colors. One of the cosmetic product line that Maybelline launched is The Loaded Bolds by Color Sensational.

One of the test that we did is smear test.


Step 1: Swatch the Matte Lipstick in our arms.

Step 2: Wait for 3 minutes to dry.

Step 3: Compress the tissue in our arms.

Step 4: Evaluate the outcome.

We swatch three different colours from the same brand which are Dynamite Red(07), Chocoholic(05) and Proud Pink(12). We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the only a little product on the tissue paper which is almost nothing.





Last but not least, we also did some long- lasting test on the product. By using applying it to our lips and test how long it is going to stay on our lips. All the colour reach the same period of time which is about two hours to lose big portion of our product from our lips. However, the shade of the colour stayed in our lips almost 6 hours until it completely gone from the lips.


Smear Test: 😁😁😁😁😁
Long lasting:😁😁😁😁
Color Pigmentation:😁😁😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁



More related review:
http://www.everything-thatmatters.com/2017/07/maybelline-color-sensational-the-loaded-bolds-lipstick-entire-collection-swatches-preview.html

Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil

Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil


Kate Fit Rare Gel Pencil is a gel pencil eyeliner.
This is new pencil eyeliner from Kate.
It comes with 1.5 mm super fine tip which suitable for makeup beginners to use.
We had tried two colors which are BK-1,BR-1
As can be seen in the picture, the colour is high coloration which is pigmented.

Apart from the superfine tip, the melting-texture also enable to draw a smooth line which easier to draw inner eyeliner and also perfect sharp eye tail.Other than that, the texture also able to draw a eyeliner with small effort used. However, this eyeliner is quite few in amount which may be use up easily. 
After applied, we have test the waterproof, smudge and etc as we do in common. 
We found out that this pen eyeliner is consider the best in waterproof, smudge-proof and long lasting.


After 6 hours applied, the result show good as the liner almost still there and the colour is same as shown in picture. Besides, it is suitable to use in hot weather thanks to the high waterproof and smudge proof as it can keep a nice look of the eye along the day.


As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof:πŸ˜πŸ˜πŸ˜€πŸ˜πŸ˜
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://www.shinilola.com/2018/08/no-makeup-makeup-challenge-with-kate.html

Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP

Kate Quick Lock Liquid Liner WP


This is another type of liquid eyeliner that launched by Kate

This type of eyeliner is aim to draw a super-fine eyeliner which produce a sharp liner.

It is the eyeliner that specially developed for Malaysia's customers.

There are only two black colour which are matte black (BK-2), and Glow black (BK-1) as shown in the picture.


This eyeliner have very high color pigmentation which look very deep in colour. 
Besides, as you will worry about the liquid liner will dry slowly but this exactly will dry faster than your expectation. Thus, it is easier to use as it dry fast which will not mess up your eye makeup. 
Moreover, thanks to superfine liner, it enable to draw eye tail perfect. 
However, it is not so suit to draw inner eyeliner as it hard due to liquid based. 
Apart from that, the best parts are there are also have strong waterproof and no smudging.


After 6 hours we use, we found out that this eyeliner can maintain the eyetail with perfect angle and will not smudge at all. 

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof:😁😁😁😁😁

Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁


More related review:
https://www.kate-global.net/sg/sp/all_products/eye_liner.html

Kate Eye Shade Marker

Kate Eye Shade Marker



There are 7 type of eyeliner that launched by Kate.
We choose eye shade marker to try as it is suitable for makeup beginner.
There only have two type of colour which are BK-1 (deep black), and BR-1 Deep brown.
Below are the color testing.


This eyeliner have high color pigmentation which the black and brown colour is deep enough.
Besides, it is a cushion fill-in marker which is easier to fill the gaps between eyelashes. The cushion tip also hold an appropriate amount of liquid which is easier to draw a beautiful liner.
Apart from that, the amazing part is their waterproof and smudge proof level as this two are the most people concern things. There are not easily removed by water and will not smudge easily as shown in picture below.


After 6 hours we use, we found out that the eyeliner is almost same with the beginning at our eyes. It only gone a bit which is considered good enough.

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)
Color pigmentation:😁😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁😁😁
Smudge proof:😁😁😁😁
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁😁

More related review:
https://dailyvanity.sg/beauty-reviews/kate-cushion-eyeliner-eye-shade-marker/

Kate Color High Vision Rouge




Kate Color High Vision Rouge

  
Apart from Kate Smooth Color rouge, Kate also launch a matte-based lipstick.
It is a lipstick with a single stoke achieves a brilliant coloration like a high-definition image. It reproduces the product color brilliantly. With glides on smoothly to give a matte finish that emphasizes the color.


We had tried three out of 10 color choices which are RD-2, RD-1 and OR-2.


We swatch three different colours from the same brand.

We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue.

This product seem to smear quite a lot compare to other products that we tested from previous blogs. Besides, it will smear more when compare with the Kate Smooth Color Rouge

For the tissue testing, we get the result for the color is easier to remove by using tissue and it is not lasting enough on lips when compare to other matte lipstick.

However, it show high pigmentation on the color which is same when apply on our lips and color look similar with some high-end lipstick.
Other than that, it is moisture and the lip line is not obvious when compare to other matte-based lipsticks. 
As a result, here are the ratings we made.
(5 is the highest)

Smear Test:  😁
Long lasting:😁😁
Color Pigmentation:😁😁😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁

More related review:
https://thoughtsofsheryl.blog/2017/10/12/review-kate-color-highvision-rouge/

Kate Smooth Color Rouge

Kate Smooth Color Rouge



It is a lipstick with brilliant coloration and smooth application which achieves strong coloration, and tight clinginess. It provides a brilliant color and luster to create the ideal lips.

There are 10 types of color option.
We took three from that which are PK-1,PK-4,and RD-1 for testing .


As usual, we will test their smear, lasting,color pigmentation, and moisture level.

Here are the color swatch and the smear test.

We swatch three different colours from the same brand.

We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue.

This product seem to smear little compare to other products that we tested from previous blogs. Besides, it will smear less when compare with the Kate High Vison Color Rouge

For the tissue testing, we get the result for the color is easier to remove by using tissue and it is not lasting enough on lips when compare to other lipstick.
It show low pigmentation on the color but it is hydrated and will not dry out your lips and thus the lip line is not obvious.
As a result, here are the ratings we made.
(5 is the highest)

Smear Test:  😁
Long lasting:😁
Color Pigmentation:😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁

More related review
http://mylife-hopes.blogspot.com/2016/06/review-kate-smooth-colour-rouge.html

Revlon Color Stay Liquid Eye Pen-Ballpoint

Revlon Color Stay Liquid Eye Pen-Ballpoint




This is pen type of liquid eyeliner which comes with pen-ballpoint.
This eyeliner only have one colour which is blackest black.
It have a quite good colour pigmentation which is black enough.
Besides, it is easier to use as with the rounded ballpoint felt tip enable to dot then trace along the lash line for a perfect liner.
Other than that, it have strong waterproof features but less in smudging proof.




After 6 hours used, we found out that the liner become lighter and the eye tail smudged away which eyes looks a bit dirty. It can be conclude that this eyeliner not suit for people who stay outdoor along the days. However, it is effortless to use as the applicator is perfect to match the eye shape.


As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁😁
Smudge proof:😁😁
Long-lasting: 😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁



More related review:
https://www.makeupalley.com/product/showreview.asp/ItemId=115495/ColorStay-Liquid-Eye-Pen/Revlon/Eyeliner

Revlon Colour Stay Liquid Liner

Revlon Colour Stay Liquid Liner 


There are 8 types of eyeliner that launched by Relvon. 

This is the revlon liquid eyeliner. It comes with two colour which are brown and black.

We had tried on the blackest black colour. 

This eyeliner have low color pigmentation as can be see in the picture. 

However, with a fine applicator tip, it enable to draw a sharp and super fine eye tail. 
Besides, it enable to draw a natural liner as the color is not deep. 
Thanks for the fine applicator, it also easier to draw the gaps between eyelashes.

Apart from that, their waterproof level is considered low which is obviously shown when compared with other's brands. However, it is no smudging. 



Thus, as usual, after 6 hours, it disappear quite a lot. We found out that this eyeliner even though is easier to use and smudge proof, but it is not suitable to use in hot weather as it will gone easily. 

As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Color pigmentation:😁
Easy to use:😁😁😁
Waterproof:😁
Smudge proof:😁😁😁

Long-lasting: 😁
Overall result:😁😁


More related review:
https://www.makeupalley.com/product/showreview.asp/ItemId=18178/ColorStay-Liquid-Liner/REVLON/Eyeliner

Revlon Ultra HD Matte Lipcolor




Ultra HD Matte Lipcolor



Ultra HD Matte Lipcolor is the high definition pigment and moisturising formula cushions your lips in vivid colour, promising a soft finish with maximum impact.

We were testing for 660 HD Romance Idylle, 650 HD Spark Etincelle and 665 HD Intensity Intensite.


We swatch three different colours from the same brand. 

We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue.


This product seem to smear quite a little compare to other products that we tested from previous blogs. 







For the tissue testing, we get the result for the colour is easier to remove by using tissue.


Last but not least, we also did some long- lasting test on the product. 

By using applying it to our lips and test how long it is going to stay on our lips. 

All the colour reach the same period of time which is about two hours to lose big portion of our product from our lips. 

However, the shade of the colour stayed in our lips almost 6 hours until it completely gone from the lips.






As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.

(5 is the highest)


Smear Test:  😁
Long lasting:😁
Color Pigmentation:😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁

More related review:
https://www.stylecraze.com/articles/revlon-ultra-hd-matte-lip-color-review/#gref

Revlon Matte balm



Revlon Matte balm




Revlon Matte alm is the crayon lipstick. 

It provide a lot of colour for the buyer so that the buyer no need to worry without the colour is no suitable for themselves. 

We choose that the colour is public which are color 240, color 210 and color 205.

 Firstly, we test the product by doing the smear test.






We swatch three different colours from the same brand. 

We evaluate the outcome every colour smear the same amount of product that contains in the tissue. 

This product seem to smear quite a little compare to other products that we tested from previous blogs.

For the tissue testing, we get the result for the colour is a bits easy to remove by using tissue.


Last but not least, we also did some long- lasting test on the product. 

By using applying it to our lips and test how long it is going to stay on our lips. 

All the colour reach the same period of time which is about two hours to lose big portion of our product from our lips. 

However, the shade of the colour stayed in our lips almost 6 hours until it completely gone from the lips.










As a result after the testing, here are the rating we made.
(5 is the highest)

Smear Test:  😁😁
Long lasting:😁
Color Pigmentation:😁😁
Moisture level:😁😁😁
Overall result:😁😁😁

More related review:
https://www.stylecraze.com/articles/revlon-colorburst-matte-balm-review/#gref